March 31, 2006
Thoughts on the Immigration Debate
There is a debate going on in Congress now that will affect Americans in so many ways. It seems nearly impossible for me to read about the immigration dilemma without being swayed one way and then the other.
This much I do know. It is a human problem that needs solving. Hopefully decisions will be made that will not break hearts and tear families apart. I hope our legislators will consider this carefully as they look for a compromise bill that will benefit us all.
As a Californian, I am concerned about our small farmers, farm workers, and our agriculture industry as a whole. I am also concerned about our tourism industry and other areas that are now the source of a living income for immigrants, legal and non-legal.
As a citizen of the United States my heart goes out to the 12 million people illegally in our country and especially to the many children. How terrible it must be to chase a dream of a better life and have that dream always out of reach - just fingertips away. How awful to live in fear of the Immigration and Naturalization Service , the police, and even the neighbor who might just turn you in.
As a teacher, I know the need to educate all children and yet I also know the drain this has put on our school system. When sometime in the 90’s our state legislators talked about keeping non-citizen children out of California schools by requiring school districts to ask for proof of legal status of all students attending , I promised myself that I would never turn a child away from my classroom door. I would quit teaching first. This wasn’t just talk. I would have done exactly that. . . ended my career before denying any child an education. Thank goodness, this bill was never passed.
Yes, our ER rooms are full of people using them for routine medical procedures. Our taxes are rising and our health insurance diminishing. Certainly these are huge problems, but realistically we can’t blame all of this on illegals. There must be a way to solve these problems in a humane and understanding way.
I believe border security is of top priority, but pales in importance to safety of those crossing the borders. I understand the death figure for people illegally crossing our desert borders over the past ten years, is close to 3,000. This is terrible. It is not right and it certainly has to stop. I am not sure that fence-building is the answer.
My thinking leans toward that of California Senator Diane Feinstein who recently stated,
“So the question before us — and I think it’s a very practical question — is, are America and Americans better served if people come out of furtive living and are able to act responsibly and have a consequential path to become legal?”
We have an opportunity to chart a new destiny for a lot of people. We have an opportunity to do something which has a chance to work, which is real, which meets the needs of real people out there, and which can stop the illegal infusion through our borders in the future if we act wisely, well and effectively.”
In the United States, we may not always agree. We may not always be correct, but isn’t it wonderful to be able to think out loud, listen, and voice our opinions?
(Visited 2432 times)





